Connect with us


Facebook is finally cracking down hard on anti-vaccine content. It is facing an uphill battle.



Open Sourced logo

After years of allowing anti-vaccine groups and pages to rack up followers on its social network, Facebook announced last month that it wants to lead the world’s largest Covid-19 inoculation information campaign and encourage its users to get vaccinated. It’s also banned users from sharing general forms of vaccine misinformation, like the idea that vaccinations cause autism.

Facebook’s big push is meant to help bring an end to a pandemic that has killed more than 2.5 million people around the world. But for some of the people who have for years been sounding the alarm about the dangers of anti-vaccine groups and pages on Facebook and Instagram, the announcement — even if it’s a step forward — feels like too little, too late.

free widgets for website

“No matter what the commitment is or the ideas made, at the end of the day … I can clearly see their priority was their job and the reputation of Facebook, versus the lives of Americans,” said vaccine advocate Ethan Lindenberger, who said that Facebook groups helped convince his mother not to vaccinate him as a child against illnesses like measles.

Over the past decade, Instagram and Facebook users have created communities on these platforms to organize against vaccines, mixing with and assuming online affinities like “vaccine safety,” parenting communities, or “health freedom,” among others. In Facebook groups, people have promoted the anti-vaccine movement by posting everything from personal anecdotes claiming vaccines have injured their children to far-out conspiracy theories, including the idea that inoculations are disingenuous money-making schemes.

Now, Facebook says it wants to change course. It’s directing users to local authorities to get information about where and how to sign up for shots. It’s also providing ad credits for public health agencies to boost vaccine content, and working with Johns Hopkins University to elevate vaccine information to groups whose access to vaccines can be lower, including Native American, Black, and Latinx communities. The company is also working with the Biden administration to tackle Covid-19 misinformation on its site.

But pro-vaccine advocates have serious doubts about whether the company fully understands the problem, and if it’s adequately prepared to address the anti-vaccine communities that flourish on its platforms.

Facebook’s vaccine campaign comes after a decade of limited action

Long before the Covid-19 pandemic, pro-vaccine advocates were trying to raise awareness about anti-vaccine content on Facebook and Instagram. Facebook groups, in particular, lured people into closed-off, online spaces that provided a sense of community, but spread medical misinformation. “I got this community of women who — like my midwife — were these supportive, intelligent, educated women who all loved their children,” recounts Maranda Dynda, a mom who joined Facebook anti-vaccine groups in 2012, before leaving these online communities about two years later. She now supports vaccines.

free widgets for website

The problem was big enough that it even personally impacted Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, who in 2016 saw his own profile swarmed by anti-vaccine comments after he posted a routine picture of his own young daughter getting vaccinated at a doctor’s visit.

While Facebook started a general fact-checking program in 2016, the company only took significant action on vaccine misinformation three years later in response to growing political pressure. Lawmakers were increasingly concerned about the surge in measles cases in the United States, and had begun paying more attention to how anti-vaccine misinformation and content discouraging vaccination had started to proliferate on social media sites like Facebook.

In March of that year, Facebook announced new changes: It would reduce the distribution of anti-vaccine groups and pages in recommendations and search. The company promised that advertisers would no longer be able to “target” audiences of people interested in vaccine-related “controversies,” and said it would reject ads with vaccine misinformation. In September 2019, the company also launched an alert that directed people to the World Health Organization (WHO) when searching for vaccine search terms, following consultation with the global public health authority.

Still, Facebook kept offering a safe place for anti-vaccine content. Groups were no longer supposed to be recommended to users in search, but they were still allowed on the platform and still adding new members. Despite its ban on ads with vaccine misinformation, it still allowed ads that pushed “opposition” to vaccines.

Unsurprisingly, anti-vaccine groups and pages continued to proliferate — and even crowdfund — on Facebook well into 2020.

free widgets for website

Between May 2019 and May 2020, nonprofit organization Avaaz found that Facebook saw a whopping 3.8 billion views on health misinformation on the platform, including on false claims about vaccines that went unflagged by Facebook fact-checkers. The Center for Countering Digital Hate, which has researched the anti-vaccine industry on social media, told Recode it found that, between March 2019 and December 2020, members of anti-vaccine groups on social media grew from just over 650,000 to just under 800,000 members — a more than 20 percent increase. Between the end of 2019 and 2020, the group also found that the number of followers of anti-vaccine accounts grew by at least 1 million people on Facebook and 4 million on Instagram, based on accounts CCDH tracked.

The Covid-19 pandemic only raised the stakes for an already significant problem. As the world got closer to approving and rolling out Covid-19 vaccines, staunch anti-vaccine groups and pages on Facebook started targeting a new audience of potential supporters that they could recruit: the millions of people nervous about the new coronavirus vaccines.

Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a longstanding anti-vaccine figure, used Instagram to elevate vaccine misinformation during the pandemic, including the false Bill Gates vaccine microchip theory. And in May 2020, “Plandemic,” a conspiracy video that accused Anthony Fauci of hiding research about supposed deleterious effects of vaccinations, went viral and got millions of interactions on Facebook. Anti-vaccine groups and pages across the platform promoted unfounded theories as they emerged, including false claims that the Covid-19 vaccine might alter your DNA, or that the entire pandemic was a conspiracy. (While the vaccines from Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna are vaccines designed with mRNA, they do not alter DNA; Covid-19 is not a hoax.)

Karen Ernst, who leads a group called Voices for Vaccines, told Recode that against the backdrop of the pandemic, anti-vaccine messaging appears to have expanded into broader communities, like those focused on organizing against mask-wearing and lockdown measures. “I hold Facebook hugely responsible,” she told Recode, in regard to the proliferation of anti-vaccine communities online. “They have been really derelict.”

Lindenberger said that to this day, Facebook remains the place where his mom gets “almost 99 percent” of the vaccine misinformation she brings up, and she remains an active member of anti-vaccine groups on the platform. He says he struggles to trust any of Facebook’s pledges.

free widgets for website

Facebook’s new rules may not be enough to combat deep-seated vaccine hesitancy

As part of its global vaccine effort — and in response to growing concern that misinformation could make people hesitant to receive the Covid-19 vaccine — Facebook has banned common strains of general vaccine misinformation. It consulted with groups like the WHO to come up with a list of specific vaccine claims users are not allowed to make, like the idea that measles can’t kill people or that vaccines cause autism. (In October 2020, Facebook had made a more limited pledge to ban ads that discourage getting vaccinated.)

Facebook said it has consulted with more than 60 health authorities and experts to design its policies. “For years, we’ve been working to stop misinformation on Facebook by reaching as many people as possible with accurate information about vaccines, removing content that breaks our rules, and reducing the distribution of false information,” Dani Lever, a spokesperson for Facebook, told Recode.

Between March and October of last year, the company removed 12 million instances of content that violate its ban on Covid-19 misinformation that could lead to imminent physical harm. Since its new policies were announced in February, the company has removed another 2 million false claims about Covid-19 and vaccines.

But experts told Recode that Facebook’s stronger rules against misinformation won’t be enough to fully address its anti-vaccine problem.

Facebook isn’t solely responsible for anti-vaccine ideology, which is as old as vaccination itself. And Facebook doesn’t have the unilateral power to stop anti-vaccine content. But the experts Recode spoke to said Facebook should have taken — or still can take — several key steps to make the conversation surrounding vaccines on Facebook healthier.

free widgets for website

“They’ve already got rules in place — they just don’t enforce them,” Imran Ahmed, the CEO of the Center for Countering Digital Hate, told Recode. A study by his organization found that of more than 500 anti-vaccine posts reported to Facebook by volunteers as misinformation, less than 6 percent were eventually removed or flagged by the platform. He says that a more effective action Facebook could take is deplatforming anti-vaccine entrepreneurs and influencers who remain on the site.

“People are really great at creating workarounds,” Kolina Koltai, a vaccine misinformation-focused postdoctoral scholar at the University of Washington, told Recode, noting that she’s still able to find misinformation and anti-vaccine Facebook groups. Koltai pointed out that although Facebook in February finally removed the Instagram page of Robert F. Kennedy Jr., his Facebook profile — where he has more than 200,000 followers — remains up. Facebook says that just because someone’s account is disabled on one of its platforms doesn’t automatically mean that their account on another service is disabled, since these accounts may post different content.

“Saying that, ‘well, we’re removing false claims and that’s going to solve the problem’ — it’s barely scratching the surface of what’s going on here,” said David Broniatowski, a professor at George Washington University who has studied anti-vaccination communities online. He notes that often, anti-vaccine groups form communities by organizing around “health freedom” and against certain government policies encouraging or requiring vaccination, and don’t necessarily focus on scientific claims about vaccines’ efficacy.

Two days after Facebook announced it would launch a global inoculation campaign, Ernst, of Voices for Vaccines, says she was able to find a six-hour-old post from a woman asking whether she should purposely expose her children to chickenpox — an illness with potentially severe complications — in a well-known anti-vaccine group. Ernst says Facebook needs a better way to report people who might be putting their children in danger.

But more broadly, experts told Recode that focusing on a particular set of claims that Facebook has deemed false and worthy of removal won’t truly combat vaccine hesitancy. Facebook does not operate in a vacuum, they argue, and spreaders of anti-vaccine content can use Facebook to find an audience, and direct them to even worse content off the platform.

free widgets for website

At the same time, pro-vaccine advocates who do outreach to vaccine-hesitant people now fear that Facebook’s takedown algorithms won’t be sensitive enough to understand the nuances of how people talk about vaccines, and so they might sometimes remove good vaccine information shared on the site. It has happened before: In 2019, for instance, Facebook’s algorithms appeared to erroneously remove pro-vaccine content launched by the Minnesota Hospital Association as it tried to better monitor vaccine content on its site.

Facebook has acknowledged the murky lines the company’s vaccine policies can raise. “[I]f your neighbor shares their personal experience of feeling sick beyond the normal side effects after getting a vaccine, is their Facebook post supposed to be removed?” wrote the company’s head of health in an op-ed this month. “There’s no perfect solution for this.”

Still, Facebook’s recent efforts are a good thing, even if the challenge of effectively beating back anti-vaccine narratives on social media can be very difficult. Wendy Sue Swanson, a pediatrician who has been writing about vaccines online since 2009, and who has met with Facebook, says that Facebook’s campaign appears to be “a multi-pronged approach” that includes tackling vaccine misinformation, but also access and distribution.

“We should be applauding and helping in these efforts, not only criticizing these efforts,” she says. She emphasized that people who know the benefits of vaccines must amplify accurate pro-vaccine information in order to truly counteract vaccine hesitancy.

“[It’s] really easy for me to just share something that’s not true,” Swanson told Recode. “[It’s] really hard for me to dissect that, and then re-prove to you an opposite opinion using facts, particularly because facts aren’t emotional, and typically lives are.”

free widgets for website

Open Sourced is made possible by Omidyar Network. All Open Sourced content is editorially independent and produced by our journalists.

Read More

See also  How to post Instagram Stories without opening the app
Continue Reading
Advertisement free widgets for website
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


LinkedIn Makes its 20 Most Popular LinkedIn Learning Courses Freely Available Throughout August





Looking to up your skills for a job change or career advancement in the second half of the year?

This will help – today, LinkedIn has published its listing of the 20 most popular LinkedIn Learning courses over the first half of 2022. In addition to this, LinkedIn’s also making each of these courses free to access till the end of the month – so now may well be the best time to jump in and brush up on the latest, rising skills in your industry.

As per LinkedIn:

As the Great Reshuffle slows and the job market cools, professionals are getting more serious about skill building. The pandemic accelerated change across industries, and as a result, skills to do a job today have changed even compared to a few years ago. Professionals are responding by learning new skills to future-proof their careers and meet the moment.” 

LinkedIn says that over seven million people have undertaken these 20 courses this year, covering everything from improved communication, project management, coding, strategic thinking and more.

free widgets for website

Here are the top 20 LinkedIn Learning courses right now, which you can access via the relevant links:

  1. Goal Setting: Objectives and Key Results (OKRs) with Jessie Withers
  2. Excel Essential Training (Office 365/Microsoft 365) with Dennis Taylor
  3. Interpersonal Communication with Dorie Clark
  4. Cultivating a Growth Mindset with Gemma Leigh Roberts
  5. Project Management Foundations with Bonnie Biafore
  6. Using Questions to Foster Critical Thinking and Curiosity with Joshua Miller
  7. Essentials of Team Collaboration with Dana Brownlee
  8. Unconscious Bias with Stacey Gordon
  9. Learning Python with Joe Marini
  10. Communicating with Confidence with Jeff Ansell
  11.  Speaking Confidently and Effectively with Pete Mockaitis
  12. Learning the OWASP Top 10 with Caroline Wong
  13. Power BI Essential Training with Gini von Courter
  14. Strategic Thinking with Dorie Clark
  15. SQL Essential Training with Bill Weinman
  16. Developing Your Emotional Intelligence with Gemma Leigh Roberts
  17. Communication Foundations with Brenda Bailey-Hughes and Tatiana Kolovou
  18. Agile Foundations with Doug Rose
  19. Digital Marketing Foundations with Brad Batesole
  20. Critical Thinking with Mike Figliuolo
See also  Should You Buy Instagram Followers in the UK?

If you’ve been thinking about upskilling, now may be the time – or maybe it’s just worth taking some of the programming courses, for example, so that you have a better understanding of how to communicate between departments on projects.

Or you could take an Agile course. If, you know, you don’t trust your own management ability.

The courses are available for free till August 31st via the above links.

Continue Reading


Instagram Is Rolling Out Reels Replies, And Will Be Testing A New Feature Which Informs …





Instagram has added a few more social features to the platform, with Reels Replies being rolled out. Along with the Replies, anew feature is being tested that shows when two users are active together in the same chat.

Reels has been performing much better than perhaps even Instagram ever anticipated. The TikTok-inspired new video format (which officially claims to have absolutely no relation to the former) had some trouble really finding its footing initially. However, Reels has grown massively and while it may not be a source of the most direct competition to TikTok, it is indeed a worthy alternative.

Reels has grown to the point that it has a massive creator program attached to it, and the video format has even been migrated to Facebook with the goal of generating further user interest there. Naturally, with such a successful virtual goldmine on its hands, Instagram has been hard at work developing new features and interface updates for Reels, integrating it more and more seamlessly into the rest of the social media platform. Features such as Reels Replies are a major part of such attempts at integration.

Reels Visual Replies are essentially just what they sound like: A Reel that is being used to reply to someone. It’s a feature that’s been seen frequently across TikTok as well. Reel Replies essentially take a user’s comments, and reply to them in video format. The comment will then show up within the Reel itself as a text-box, taking up some amount of space, and showing both the user who issued said comment along with the text. The text-box is apparently adjustable, with users having the ability to move it around and change its size depending on where it obstructs one’s Reel the least.

See also  Adele framed Celine Dion's used gum | — Australia's leading news site

Overall, it’s a fun addition to the Reels format, even if the credit should be going to TikTok first. At any rate, it’s an example of Instagram really utilizing Reels’ social media capabilities, outside of just serving it up as a form of entertainment.

free widgets for website

Speaking of social media capabilities, a new feature might help alleviate one of the most common frustrations encountered across all such platforms. Isn’t it annoying when you see that a friend’s online, but isn’t replying to your chat? Sure, they’ve probably just put their phone down to run a quick errand, but there’s no way for you to know, right? Well, there sort of is now! Instagram is beta testing a new feature via which if both users are active within a chat, the platform will display that accordingly. It’s a work-around, sure, and one that’s currently being tested for usefulness, but it’s still a very nice, and even fresh, addition to the social media game.

Now, the active status will only appear when you are both active at the same time.#Instagram #instgramnewfeature@MattNavarra @instagram @alex193a

— Yash Joshi  (@MeYashjoshi) December 10, 2021

Read next: Instagram Plans On Allowing Users To Return To Its Old Chronologically Sorted News Feed

Continue Reading


5 apps for scheduling Instagram posts on iPhone and Android





Alright, we get it. You’re an Instagram Nostradamus.

You know exactly what you want to post and when you’re gonna want to post it. Maybe there’s a meme or comment you want to make that you know will be totally relevant for a future moment or event. Or it could be that you’re an influencer and you want to make sure you keep a steady stream of content coming, so you want to schedule posts for times when you know you won’t be active (or won’t have internet access).

You’ll be happy to know there are apps that are specialized for just such situations. So listen up, InstaNostradamuses…Instagrostra…Instadam…Insta…uh…you guys (we’ll workshop it. No we won’t. We’ll probably just abandon that effort completely. You’re welcome) — these are the Instagram-post-scheduling apps for you.

While all of the iPhone apps below are free to download, they all have some in-app purchases.

1. Planoly


We’ll start with “official partner” of Instagram, itself, Planoly — an Instaplanner that uses a grid to let you plan, schedule, and publish posts (as well as Reels) on Instagram. The app also lets you see post metrics and analytics so you can make sure your post didn’t flop.

Planoly is available for iOS on the Apple App Store and the Google Play store for Android.

free widgets for website

2. Buffer

BufferCredit: buffer / app store

Buffer is another Instagram post scheduler that helps you plan your posts and analyze feedback once they’re published. Use a calendar view to drag and drop posts into days/time slots for easy scheduling.

See also  Commerce and Culture Collide

Buffer is available for iOS on the Apple App Store and the Google Play store for Android.

3. Preview

PreviewCredit: preview / app store

Preview offers typical post-scheduling tools and analytics along with a few helpful extras. Get caption ideas, recommendations for hashtags, and more.

Preview is available for iOS on the Apple App Store and the Google Play store for Android.

4. Content Office

Content OfficeCredit: content office / app store

An Instagram post scheduler with a visual boost, Content Office allows users to plan and schedule Instagram posts while learning “marketing and visual guides to grow your brand on Instagram.” Like aesthetics and using visuals to create cohesive themes? Maybe this is the Instaplanner for you.

free widgets for website

Content Office is available for iOS on the Apple App Store.

5. Plann

PlannCredit: plann / apple store

You’ll never guess what “Plann” lets you do…

Aside from scheduling posts, get content ideas and recommendations, as well as strategy tips to ensure you’re maximizing your Instagram engagement. Ever wonder when the best time to post something is? Plann can offer you some help with that.

Plann is available for iOS on the Apple App Store and the Google Play store for Android.

free widgets for website
Continue Reading